Short answer: a free website audit should identify visible problems without promising results: clarity of the offer, mobile display, contact, titles, indexing, sitemap, weak pages, broken links, supporting evidence and local consistency. It helps determine whether a straightforward fix is enough or a redesign needs to be planned.
A useful audit should not produce an endless report. It should identify what is actually getting in the way of enquiries.
The main message
Can visitors quickly understand what you do, where you work and why they should contact you?
Mobile display and contact
Is the website readable on a phone? Does the form work? Is the call button easy to access?
Local SEO
Are the titles, descriptions, service pages, service areas, Google profile and reviews consistent?
Supporting evidence
Does the website show completed work, photos, reviews, guarantees or concrete examples?
Key point
A good audit leads to concrete actions rather than a list of criticisms that is impossible to prioritise.
Try a customer’s route in ten minutes
- Open a service page on a phone without going through the home page. Write down the trade and the area you can identify straight away.
- Follow the route to an enquiry. Look for a visible form or contact details, and check whether the page tells you what information to send.
- If you have Search Console access, filter the Performance report by the exact page URL. Record the clicks, impressions and queries for the last 28 days.
Save the URL and a screenshot for each issue. For another pair of eyes, see what I check in a free first review.
Simple fix or redesign: how to decide
A free audit is only worth what was actually examined, so ask. Reading the public website can assess the message, mobile display, contact route and evidence. Without Search Console access, it says nothing reliable about real searches or indexing. The decision then depends on the type of problem. Example: an unclear title or an oversized photograph can be fixed where it is, while a website you cannot access, or whose theme blocks changes, points towards a redesign.
- Ask someone unfamiliar with your business to find your service, area and a way to write to you on a phone, unaided.
- Ask for a ranked list: what blocks contact, what weakens trust, then the rest.
- Check that each finding names the page concerned and how to reproduce the problem.